I don't use any other Curl Keeper products so can only review this as a standalone. Used this today on my 2c/3a wave/curls and it's everything I hoped it would be. Really revitalised my hair and extended my wash day which is brilliant. Just experimenting with it at the monebt, but what worked for me was to section my hair, spritz first with water then spray each section with this refresh, scrunched, diffused and then SOTC with a few drops of hair oil. Amazing and I'm now a firm fan.My hair doesn't seem producty and has a good shine too. Fantastic.